Jump to content
Main menu
Main menu
move to sidebar
hide
Navigation
Main page
Recent changes
Random page
Help using our Wiki
Stationery Wiki
Search
Search
Appearance
Log in
Personal tools
Log in
Pages for logged out editors
learn more
Contributions
Talk
Editing
The Pen Addict 240/transcript
(section)
Page
Discussion
British English
Read
Edit
View history
Tools
Tools
move to sidebar
hide
Actions
Read
Edit
View history
Refresh
General
What links here
Related changes
Special pages
Page information
Appearance
move to sidebar
hide
Warning:
You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you
log in
or
create an account
, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
Anti-spam check. Do
not
fill this in!
== Mont Blanc Bonheur == '''Myke Hurley:''' A couple of weeks ago, we spoke about the Mont Blanc Bonheur. And when I say we spoke about it, we got a little bit upset. And we shouted for a while about this pen, which was created by Mont Blanc for women and marketed explicitly as such. A couple of days after the show, I was in a department store. We were buying furniture. And I actually saw one of these in the Mont Blanc stand. And it is a very good-looking pen, except for the fact that they put a little jewel on the end, like on the cap. Which kind of ruins a lot of what I like about it. It kind of makes it look a little bit tacky. Not on the cap. It's on the end of the pen, right? But, yeah, I didn't really like that part. But the rest of it looked really good. And I explained it to Idina why we were so mad about it. And she thought it was kind of ridiculous. But at the time, we were kind of under the feeling of like, well, I think even you said, right, at the time that Applebaum, who are selling the pen, they used marketing copy that frustrated us both. But at the time, you were willing to kind of just give them a pass and say, well, this is what they're being told by Mont Blanc to say. Yeah. Yeah. And then, I'm frustrated we even have to talk about this now. But Applebaum posted to their Instagram account a picture of the Bonner on top of a bra. '''Brad Dowdy:''' A black lace bra. '''Myke Hurley:''' Of course. I forget the important details. Sitting on top of a black lace bra. And this was maybe, I can't remember who sent it to us, but then me and you both got really mad on social media and started tweeting at the Appleboom account. They didn't really seem to care and or understand what we were talking about. But we were really mad about it. And Tiff, before we kind of move on with this, I want to get your opinion on this. What do you think about the marketing of this pen? How does it make you feel? '''Tiff Arment:''' I think it's rather ridiculous. It feels pandering. You know what I mean? Like, you guys, we just talked about a pink pen in pink gold, right? And it had really nothing to do with women. It was talking about a flower, right? And the marketing of that, the platinum pen. So, this pen being marketed like this, it's just so ridiculous. It's absolutely ridiculous. Like, why is it on a bra? Who writes with their pens topless? Like, who's doing this? Oh, yeah, because that's what it is, right? Like, I didn't realize that. That's what it's applying. It's like, oh, let me just, you know, relax, take off my bra and use my fountain pen. Like, come on. '''Myke Hurley:''' Let me just put it down for a moment. '''Tiff Arment:''' Yeah. And obviously, the bra came off first and you were using because the pen is on top of the bra, right? So, I mean, like, what is that implying? Like, and plus, when you use a fountain pen, it's at your desk. Another place where you're typically not without your bra. Like, it just, come on. I mean, it's one step away from seeing, like, a sexy model only wearing lingerie holding the pen seductively. Right? '''Myke Hurley:''' Like, I mean, and it is only a stone's throw from that at this point. Yeah, exactly. It's super close. '''Tiff Arment:''' It's just ridiculous. And if it's trying to market towards women because it's the ladies pen for, you know, our lady brains, like, or whatever they're trying to say. It's like, well, we don't want to see it with sexy lingerie, right? Because, I mean, the majority of us, I mean, come on. It does. That's. It's just. It just feels. I'm trying to put. This is. It's tricky. I thought I was going to have some good jokes to talk about this, but now I'm just getting mad. Because, like, it's like, yes, ladies like nice things. Ladies like lace and frilly stuff and everything. But then it's also, like, you're not a real woman unless you like this stuff. Or you aren't pretty if you don't have sexy lingerie. You know what I mean? Like, so there's, like, all these tricky, messed up messages. It's like, it's a pen. Get it. Get it off my bra. It's not like it has nothing to do with it. Yeah. And I thought the Twitter responses to that picture also are pretty insane. Like, some people are like, ooh la la. I'm like, ew, shut up. And then, like, and then there are a couple of them saying how ridiculous of a marketing campaign that is. And so that was good to see. '''Brad Dowdy:''' Yeah. So, like, on the one hand, like, pen companies have been doing this for a long time, right? I mean, as long as there have been pen companies, they've been making such and such for women. And, you know, it's hopefully changing over the years that they're realizing that, okay, this is not necessary to market a pen like that. Just like you said, we fawned over a pink and rose gold pen because it's an awesome pen. We would do the same thing with this Bonheur because it looks just awesome. It can be a pen for anyone. And the marketing is just super strange. And I was willing to, okay, we talked about it and we're done and it's going to happen again. Some other company is going to come up with something and we'll talk about it again. And, you know, Applebaum had no skin in the game. They were, you know, working with Montblanc, you know, as a Montblanc dealer using Montblanc copy for the pen. Great. So then yesterday, Applebaum took it upon themselves to do this picture. And that really set me off. Like, I was pretty upset about it and was tweeting at them, you know. So, and Yost, who is the owner of Applebaum, started, finally later in the afternoon, after they had went on a rash of, like, replies to, like, some of my questions, you know, saying, like, well, why isn't the men's pen marketed with men's underwear and stuff like that? '''Brad Dowdy:''' The response I got, and I'm not pulling this tweet up, was essentially, I can't wait to see that picture. This is from Applebaum. Um, and I was like, wait a minute. Something's not right here. So, like, here's one that they sent to me. '''Myke Hurley:''' And it's like, it's just, it's just like, it's like they give with one hand and take with another. It's like, of course women can use all pens. But the Bonner is marketed, especially for the ladies around us. It's like, oh, my God. Like, so close. And then you just, you just snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. Yep. Like, why? '''Brad Dowdy:''' So, Yost sent me a, several messages. We talked back and forth a bunch yesterday. That part got lost in the translation, the tweet responses stuff. He thought we were joking around with them. Um, and he responded accordingly. And he's like, I just didn't understand that. And he apologized. And, you know, he understands what we're trying to say now. He never really said anything about the pic. Other than, he's like, you know what? Our next door neighbor, retail neighbor, is a lingerie store. We thought it would be fun to go do this. I'm like, okay. I had, I like, I disagree with that. We're going to end up just, you know, I essentially said that. And, um, but there were, the, the Twitter responses were a definite, definite loss in translation issue. I fully believe that. They didn't mean any harm by that. Um, I don't think, I just think there's some cultural differences to where they don't, they have no issue with the picture. It seems like to me without saying that directly. Um, they're like perfectly fine with that. And, you know, uh, I'm not like on Twitter. '''Myke Hurley:''' Like they, they said that, you know, I mean, I don't know if it really means anything specifically, but they did, they did apologize. Uh, but it's one of those, like, we're sorry you got offended type of apologies. '''Tiff Arment:''' I'm sorry. You feel bad. '''Brad Dowdy:''' Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. So it was an interesting day on the Twitters yesterday, but you know, I mean, what are you going to, I'm, I'm not going to not say something after we've just talked about that. I mean, that was, that was too far. Like, okay, Montblanc's marketing the pen towards women. It's silly. It's dumb. It's ridiculous. It's unnecessary. This took it to a different place, which I was like super not comfortable with. '''Tiff Arment:''' I mean, with any pen though, like why even have gender specific marketing? Like all you need to do is have different styles of pens and it's like people will gravitate towards the one that they are attracted to. And by putting a gender on it in the marketing, it's making one side feel bad that they can't, that they shouldn't want that pen because it's for somebody else or make someone else feel, you know what I mean? It's, it's, it's, it's making it, it's, it's separating it in a way that shouldn't have been separated in the first place because it's a pen. Like again, put a flower behind it, have it be a color and whoever likes that color or that style will go to it. It doesn't have to be about being a man or being a woman to have this type of pen. Like that's, what's ridiculous about it. And again, the same with like an all black, like cement looking brutalist masculine pen too. Like, you know what I mean? You don't have to have like a football behind it or something in order to show that this is for the dudes, you know? You just have to have it out there. And if a woman likes that style, she's going to buy that pen. If a man likes that style, he's going to buy that pen. It has nothing to do with, you know, what's in your, under your bra. Right. '''Myke Hurley:''' Like it was, you know, like with the, what I said last time with the copy, like the copy, he talks about adding glamour and luxury to your life, which you could just, you can still say that. '''Brad Dowdy:''' I think talismanic was one of the words, but yeah, you could totally say all these things without invoking any gender. '''Myke Hurley:''' Yeah. '''Brad Dowdy:''' It's like, I like to add glamour and luxury to my life, you know? '''Myke Hurley:''' Why not? But it's, it's. My son's favorite color is pink sparkles. '''Tiff Arment:''' No, purple sparkles. That's right. '''Myke Hurley:''' It's just, it's just strange. It is just strange. And, you know, I didn't know if I wanted to get, go down this road again today, but I feel like it's worth, it's just worth talking about. Cause it's worth mentioning that we kind of gave Applebaum a pass on this and they kind of screwed the pooch on this one. I think I don't really think they did a good job of all of this. I hope that they learn from it. Like it's just not necessary. It's just not necessary. Right. Right. It didn't do anything. All of their other Montblanc pens are taken on top of notebooks or tables, you know, on their Instagram account. Like they made a specific choice with this one and they needn't have. Yep. Let's talk about a company that, that keeps their underwear and their pens separate. And that's pen chalet. We love pen chalet because they have all of the pens that you're looking for, all of the brands that you want and are an authorized dealer. You know, I'm going to keep my eye on pen chalet to see if they're going to get this platinum 3776 in at some point. Because they, I know I'm going to get great customer service. I'm going to get great shipping rates. And I'm also going to get a discount as well because I listened to this show. I don't know if you're aware of that. They have a super great customer service, very fast, very reliable. They do free shipping on orders of over $50 in the United States. They also sell internationally with very reasonable shipping rates. They have lots of accessories and refills and inks and converters and stuff like that as well. They're always doing great discounts. They're doing closeout specials every couple of weeks. Pen chalet has a 100% satisfaction guarantee on their high quality pens that they sell at low prices. As always, go to penchalet.com, P-E-N-C-H-A-L-E-T.com. Click the podcast link at the top of the website. Enter the password penaddict for this week's special offer. And to get the code that you want to save 10% on anything at pen chalet, that's where you want to go. So you want to use that password penaddict to get into the special secret penaddict listener area. And you'll get the code that you need to save anything. Save 10% on anything over at pen chalet. Now this week's offer is 50% on all of the Jin Hao pens that pen chalet have in stock. What do you think about this one? '''Brad Dowdy:''' So I don't know the different levels. Like there's an X450, X750, 159. I don't know what each of the different model numbers dictate. But what I do know is that people buy these Jin Hao's by the bucket full. Because they're really good quality for a really low price. People who I've read about them, I have not used them. I've read all the reviews about them. They're like, wow, this is a surprisingly great pen for less than $5, you know, in some cases. It's a wonderful way to test out different inks. You might be scared about trying an Iron Gall ink and another pen. Put it in this pen to see how it works. Because it's not going to, you're not going to lose anything. I know people who buy, like I said, buy these by the handful to work on nibs themselves. Because it's a cheap way to get a quality pen. And you're not worried about doing damage to it. But you can manipulate it and have fun. That's what I think of when I think of like Jin Hao. It's like a bulk pen while it still remains a quality writing instrument. It just allows you to play around a little bit more. And not have to worry necessarily about ruining your $200 pen. If you want to put that crazy ink in it. Or you want to mix inks and see, you know, what happens. This is the kind of pen for that. And when you're shopping, it's kind of a no-brainer at this price point. To add like one or three to your cart. And just have them laying around the house to mess around with. So they're very cool for that. '''Myke Hurley:''' Yeah, talking price, right? You've got three different ones here. One's $4.46, one's $5.03, and one's $5.64. Yep, these are super cheap. These are super, super cheap. So you can go check them out today. Go to penchalet.com. P-E-N-C-H-A-L-E-T.com. Thank you so much to Penchalet for their continued support of this show. And Relay FM. We love them. They're the best.
Summary:
Please note that all contributions to Stationery Wiki are considered to be released under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike (see
Stationery Wiki:Copyrights
for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource.
Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!
Cancel
Editing help
(opens in new window)